Massey’s Frozen Custard: The Best Frozen Treat in Carlisle, PA

If you’re in Carlisle on a hot summer day or looking for a sweet Father’s Day treat, then you need to stop by Massey’s Frozen Custard! In this episode of Homemade PA, we are going inside this local favorite to get the scoop on all things ice cream!

How it Started

Massey’s was established back in 1949 by the Massey family and has been a community staple ever since. We met up with current owner Amber White and she told us about the history of Massey’s, how they make their custard, and the delicious treats they serve.

Since Massey’s opened, it has changed ownership five times. Though the ownership changed, the recipes and traditions remained the same. From the beginning, they have offered their own recipes for classic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and raspberry and each of these classics are still on the menu today. They also make custom hand dip flavors that they cycle through such as chocolate peanut butter cup, coffee, and many more!

Classic Frozen Treats

While there, Amber showed us how to make one of Rebecca’s favorites, the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Arctic Mount! An arctic mount is another signature on their menu and is like a blizzard from Dairy Queen (but better because it’s real custard)! Each customer gets to choose either chocolate or vanilla soft serve as well as a candy add in such as peanut butter cups, Oreo cookie pieces, cookie dough, and more. Rebecca chose chocolate ice cream paired with peanut butter cups and got to make this delicious creation from beginning to end!

Another classic at Massey’s is their Chocolate, Vanilla Soft Serve Twist; a simple favorite that has been around forever! You can get this delicious treat in a bowl, regular cone, sugar cone, or waffle cone. You can also choose to add either chocolate or rainbow sprinkles. Rebecca also got to make this creation, learning that it takes a bit of practice to make the perfect ice cream cone.

Other menu items include a variety of custom hand dipped ice cream flavors, shakes, malts, banana splits, sundaes, ice cream cakes, soft drinks, floats, and slushies. To find out what custom flavors are currently being offered, you can visit Massey’s Facebook page where they regularly update their current flavors.

Upcoming Discounts

With Father’s Day just around the corner, Massey’s is the perfect place to get your dad a special treat! Come into the shop and order a Banana Split for just $3.50! A great discount just for dads on their special day. You can also order an ice cream cake for your Father’s Day celebration made with any of their custom flavors and finished with your choice of wording.

Visit Today!

If you are a local of Carlisle or new to the area, Massey’s is a classic summer treat you can’t pass up! Additionally, if you are looking to buy, build or refinance, make sure you reach out to our team, and we will be happy to assist you. Don’t forget to subscribe to our channel so you never miss an episode of Homemade PA and stay tuned to see what we feature next!